Divine Lofthouse Cookies: 1 Secret Trick

When I first started Reciqa, I wanted to create a space where baking felt less like a chore and more like a joyful adventure. For me, cooking has always been about bringing people together—sharing a warm plate, laughing around the table, and creating those little moments that stick with you. I promise you’ll find simple, delicious things here, from everyday dinners to the kind of indulgent desserts that make people ask for the recipe immediately. So pull up a chair, let’s get messy, and let’s make something wonderful!

Today, we are talking about the ultimate throwback treat: Lofthouse Cookies. Forget those dry, crumbly things you sometimes find at the grocery store. I’ve cracked the code on the softest, cake-like cookies imaginable, all topped with that gorgeous, fluffy buttercream frosting. You won’t believe how simple these bakery favorites are to whip up right in your own kitchen!

Why You Will Love These Lofthouse Cookies

These aren’t just good cookies; they are the cookies you dream about when you need a real sugar rush. They come together faster than you think, especially once you get the hang of the mix! Seriously, these are my go-to when I need a quick showstopper.

• The texture is unbelievably soft and pillowy—just like the ones you pay too much for at the mall bakery.
• They use simple ingredients, but the combination creates pure magic.
• You get that perfect, slightly tangy buttercream that balances the sweetness.
• No complicated rolling pins or fancy cutters needed for these Lofthouse Cookies.
• They are incredibly easy to customize with whatever fun sprinkles you have on hand!

Assembling Your Lofthouse Cookies Ingredients

Okay, before we even think about turning on the mixer, let’s look at what we need. I promise, this list looks long, but it’s really just two simple groups: the cookie base and that incredible frosting. The secret to these cookies is making sure your butter and margarine are truly soft, but not melted. And for the egg? Make sure it’s at room temperature—it blends so much better!

I always lay everything out on the counter first, just like a little mise en place station. It saves so much time when you get in the flow!

Cookie Dough Components

Ingredient	Amount	Preparation Note
Powdered Sugar	1 1/3 cups	For creaming
Margarine	1 stick (1/2 cup)	Softened
Unsalted Butter	1 stick (1/2 cup)	Softened
Large Egg	1	Room temperature
Vanilla Extract	1 teaspoon
Almond Extract	1/4 teaspoon	Don’t skip this!
Cake Flour	3 cups	Whisked with dry ingredients
Cornstarch	2 teaspoons
Baking Soda, Baking Powder, Cream of Tartar, Salt	1 teaspoon each (except 1/4 tsp salt)	Whisked together

The Perfect Buttercream Frosting

This frosting is what makes the cookie truly sing. You need a whole cup of butter here, so make sure you have two sticks ready to go!

Ingredient	Amount	Preparation Note
Unsalted Butter	2 sticks (1 cup)	Softened
Powdered Sugar	4 cups
Vanilla Extract	2 teaspoons
Milk	1/2 cup
Salt	1/4 teaspoon	To balance the sweetness
Food Coloring	Pink/Red (as needed)	For that classic look
Rainbow Sprinkles	2 tablespoons	For topping!

Baking Your Soft Lofthouse Cookies Perfectly

Now for the fun part—turning those measured ingredients into actual cookies! Remember, the goal here is soft, tender, and cake-like, so we need to be gentle with the mixing.

Mixing the Lofthouse Cookies Dough Base

First up, we tackle the fats and sugar. Get your powdered sugar, margarine, and softened butter into a big bowl. You need to cream these together for a good couple of minutes until they look smooth and pale. If it looks grainy, just keep going! Once that’s looking dreamy, add your room temperature egg, vanilla, and that crucial almond extract. Mix until it’s just combined.

In a separate bowl, whisk all your dry stuff together—the cake flour, cornstarch, leaveners, and salt. This is important because it helps distribute the baking soda and cream of tartar evenly. Now, add the dry mix to the wet mix slowly, on low speed. I mean it—low speed! As soon as you see the last streaks of flour disappear, STOP the mixer. Overmixing develops gluten, and gluten equals tough cookies, which is the opposite of what we want for our perfect Lofthouse Cookies.

Chilling and Shaping the Lofthouse Cookies

This next step is non-negotiable if you want that signature thick bakery shape. Wrap that soft dough up tight and let it chill in the fridge for at least an hour. Trust me, it firms up beautifully and prevents them from spreading into flat pancakes when they hit the heat.

When the hour is up, preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C) and line those baking sheets with parchment paper. Scoop out about a tablespoon and a half of dough per cookie, roll it into a nice little ball, and place them about two inches apart on the sheet. Then, take your palm and gently press each ball down just a little bit. They don’t need to be perfectly flat, just slightly flattened domes.

Baking and Cooling for Softness

Pop those trays in the oven for 8 to 10 minutes. The key here is watching the edges—they should just look set, and the tops should still look pale, maybe a hint of light gold around the rim. If you wait until they are brown, you’ve gone too far and they’ll be hard! Pull them out immediately when they look done.

Leave them on the hot baking sheet for about five minutes after they come out. This lets them firm up slightly before you move them. Then, carefully transfer them to a wire rack to cool completely. Seriously, they must be totally cool, or that beautiful frosting will melt right off!

Crafting the Classic Buttercream Frosting for Lofthouse Cookies

This frosting isn’t just icing; it’s the fluffy, sugary cloud that holds the whole experience together. If you want that authentic bakery look and feel, you have to treat the butter right! We start with two full sticks of softened butter—no shortcuts here. Beat that butter by itself until it looks truly creamy and lightened up. This initial whipping is what builds the volume.

Once the butter is happy, start adding your four cups of powdered sugar, but do it slowly, on low speed! If you dump it all in, you’ll have a sugar explosion that coats your entire kitchen, trust me, I’ve learned that the hard way! After the sugar is incorporated, we add the vanilla, the milk, and the salt. Turn the mixer up to medium speed and let it whip for a good three or four minutes until it becomes airy and almost white. That’s the texture you’re aiming for!

Achieving the Right Frosting Consistency

Consistency is everything for spreading. If it looks too stiff after whipping, add milk just one teaspoon at a time until it’s easily spreadable with a small offset spatula. If it somehow gets too thin, just add another quarter cup of powdered sugar. The goal is a thick, spreadable paste that holds its shape on the cookie.

Coloring and Sprinkling Your Lofthouse Cookies

This is where the fun really starts! For that iconic look, I use just a few drops of pink or red food coloring. Mix it in until the color is perfectly uniform. You want a lovely, soft pastel shade, not a shocking neon color unless that’s your thing! Once your Lofthouse Cookies are completely cool and frosted, grab those rainbow sprinkles. Don’t be shy! Give them a generous shower of sprinkles right before the frosting sets up. They look best when they are piled high with color.

Tips for Expert Lofthouse Cookies Success

I want you to have the absolute best results when you tackle this recipe. Even small deviations can change the texture from soft cake to chewy cookie, and we definitely don’t want that! Over the years, I’ve learned a few non-negotiables that guarantee that pillowy texture you’re chasing. These little tricks are what separate a good cookie from a truly spectacular, bakery-worthy batch of Lofthouse Cookies.

Ingredient Temperature Matters for Lofthouse Cookies

When the recipe calls for softened butter, it means soft, not melty! If your butter is too warm or greasy, it won’t cream properly with the powdered sugar. That creaming process is what traps air, and that trapped air is what gives your cookie its lift and lightness. Similarly, use a room temperature egg. Cold eggs can cause the creamed butter mixture to curdle or seize up slightly, leading to a denser final product. Patience here pays off big time in the end! For more on ingredient science, check out this resource on creaming butter and sugar.

Avoiding Over-Spreading Dough

If you’ve ever made these and ended up with thin, crispy discs instead of soft mounds, I bet you skipped the chilling step! I know it’s tempting to just mix and bake, but the fats in the dough need time to firm up in the cold. When the chilled dough hits the warm oven, it melts slowly, allowing the leavening agents to work before the cookie spreads too thin. If you skip chilling, the cookies spread immediately, resulting in a flat texture we are trying desperately to avoid. If you are interested in other cookie recipes that require chilling, check out these hazelnut cookies.

Frequently Asked Questions About Lofthouse Cookies

I get so many questions about these cookies because everyone wants that perfect bakery result at home! It’s usually just a few little tweaks that make all the difference between a good cookie and a truly amazing one. Ask away, I’m happy to help you nail these sweet treats!

Can I use regular all-purpose flour instead of cake flour for Lofthouse Cookies?

You can, but I really advise against it if you are chasing that signature soft, cake-like texture. Cake flour has a lower protein content than all-purpose flour, which means less gluten develops when you mix the dough. Less gluten equals a more tender crumb! If you absolutely must substitute, use all-purpose flour, but reduce the amount slightly and maybe add an extra half teaspoon of cornstarch to try and mimic that softness. Just know they will be slightly chewier than the classic Lofthouse Cookies.

How long do homemade Lofthouse Cookies stay fresh?

These are best eaten within the first two days, especially with that rich buttercream frosting on top. They store surprisingly well, though! Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature. If you stack them, put a small piece of parchment paper between the layers so the frosting doesn’t stick together. Don’t refrigerate them unless your kitchen is super hot, because the butter in the frosting can get rock hard and the cookie itself might dry out faster in the fridge.

What is the key to getting the cake-like texture in these Lofthouse Cookies?

It’s a combination of three things working together! First, using cake flour. Second, the cream of tartar. It reacts with the baking soda to give a specific kind of lift and softness that regular baking powder alone can’t achieve. And finally, you absolutely cannot overmix the dough once the flour goes in. Mix only until the streaks disappear. That careful handling is how you lock in that delicate, melt-in-your-mouth texture!

Storing Your Homemade Lofthouse Cookies

Look, these cookies are so good, you might not have leftovers! But if you do manage to save some of these soft beauties, proper storage is key to keeping that frosting fluffy and the cookie tender. The biggest mistake people make is sticking them in the fridge right away. That makes the cookie firm up—we want soft!

For short-term storage, just use a good airtight container right on the counter. If you’re stacking them, use small squares of wax paper between the layers. If you need to keep them longer, say for up to a week, then the fridge is your friend, but bring them out about an hour before you want to eat them so they can come back to room temperature. They don’t really reheat well, so eating them cool or room temp is best.

Storage Method	Duration	Best Practice
Airtight Container (Counter)	3-4 Days	Use parchment squares between frosted layers.
Airtight Container (Refrigerator)	Up to 1 Week	Allow 1 hour on counter to soften before eating.
Freezing Dough Balls	Up to 3 Months	Bake from frozen, adding 3-5 minutes to bake time.

Sharing Your Baking Journey

Honestly, seeing your creations is the best part of my whole day! I pour my heart into these recipes, hoping they bring a little bit of joy and comfort to your kitchen, just like they do mine. I truly want to know how these turned out for you. Did your frosting turn out perfectly fluffy? Did you try a different sprinkle color?

Don’t be shy! Drop a comment down below and tell me what you thought. Your feedback helps me tweak things for the next person who tries this recipe. If you loved them, please consider leaving a quick rating—it really helps other folks find these fun recipes. Happy baking, and I can’t wait to hear all about your beautiful cookies!

Print